| 2024 |
Michelle Enke, Wichita Public Library |
| 2023 |
Matthew Rutherford, Newberry Library, Chicago, Illinois |
| 2022 |
Cheryl Lang, Midwest Genealogy Center, Independence, Missouri |
| 2021 |
David E. Rencher, Family History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah |
| 2020 |
Kris Rzepczynski, Archives of Michigan, Lansing, Michigan |
| 2019 |
Susan Kaufman, Clayton Genealogical Research Center, Houston, Texas |
| 2018 |
Timothy Gleisner, Library of Michigan, Lansing, Michigan |
| 2017 |
Larry W. Cates, High Point Public Library, High Point, North Carolina |
| 2016 |
Drew Smith, Tampa Library, University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida |
| 2015 |
Scott Holl, St. Louis County Library, St. Louis, Missouri |
| 2014 |
Dr. Sandra G. Treadway, Library of Virginia, Richmond, Virginia |
| 2013 |
Elizabeth Crabtree Wells, Samford University, Birmingham, Alabama |
| 2012 |
Debbi Lyon, Blasco Memorial Library, Erie, Pennsylvania |
| 2011 |
Tim Blevins, Manager, Special Collections, Pikes Peak Library District |
| 2010 |
Randy Riley, Manager, Special Collections, Library of Michigan |
| 2009 |
No nominees met the qualifications for the Filby Award in 2009) |
| 2008 |
David Dearborn, New England Historic Genealogical Society, Boston, Massachusetts |
| 2007 |
Curt Bryan Witcher, Allen County Library, Ft. Wayne, Indiana |
| 2006 |
Eric Grundset, DAR Library, Washington, District of Columbia |
| 2005 |
Ron D. Bryant, Kentucky Historical Society and the Kentucky State Parks Department |
| 2004 |
James Jeffrey, Denver Public Library, Denver, Colorado |
| 2003 |
Carole C. Callard (1941–2005), Library of Michigan, Lansing, Michigan |
| 2002 |
Jim Hansen, Wisconsin Historical Society Library, Madison, Wisconsin |
| 2001 |
Martha Henderson, Mid-Continent Public Library, Independence, Missouri |
| 2000 |
Pamela Hall Cooper, Indian River County Public Library, Vero Beach, Florida |
| 1999 |
Lloyd DeWitt Bockstruck, Dallas Public Library, Dallas, Texas |